In 2005 I won two trips worth about $5,000 each. I went on one. The other expired without me, and I paid tax on it anyway, because prizes count as income whether or not you use them. It was non-transferrable, so it didn’t reach anyone else either. A prize you never claimed isn’t a neutral thing. It’s a bill.
Both wins landed the same year. I can’t tell you which came first, since my records from that era are pieced together from an old blog and the dates are approximate. Same year, same value, opposite endings. The difference between them is the only useful thing I have to hand you.
What made one trip possible and the other impossible?
The one I took was a NASCAR trip to Atlanta. I was one of ten finalists at a Jeff Gordon key-turn event, and I didn’t win the Tahoe. What I got was VIP race access, airfare, a hotel, and $500 to spend.
Getting there was the hard part. The airport, the flight, the leaving-my-house part. Once I’d arrived, somebody else’s schedule ran the day. I didn’t have to decide where to be or when. That’s the piece I’d underrate for years afterward.
I need to say plainly what was going on, and then I’m going to move on from it. I was in a bad place mentally in 2005 and I struggled to even leave the house. When I won the second trip, I felt nothing but guilt. Not delight, not luck. Guilt.
The other prize was a Sports Dream Package: a trip to anywhere in the United States, for any major sporting event I wanted. On paper it’s the better prize. On paper it’s the dream. In practice it handed me a blank page and asked me to fill it in, and a blank page was exactly what I couldn’t do that year.
I tried. I kept meaning to work up the nerve. I kept coming up with reasons it wasn’t the right month, and there were real limits attached too, on timing and location, which gave the excuses somewhere to live. Then it expired. I’m not proud of this at all.
Do you pay taxes on a prize you never claimed?
Yes. I got a 1099 covering both trips, on a combined value of about $10,000, including the one I never set foot on.
So the trip didn’t quietly disappear. It cost me money. That’s the part I’d want to know if I were you, because “I’ll just let it go” sounds free and it isn’t.
It gets worse in a way I didn’t think about until much later. The prize was non-transferrable. I couldn’t hand it to a friend, couldn’t pass it to my sister, couldn’t give it to anyone who would have been thrilled by it. Somebody out there entered that sweepstakes and didn’t win, and what they lost to was me, and then I didn’t use it. It went nowhere. That feels crappy.
The rule I took from it isn’t the one you’d expect
For a long time I told myself the lesson was to only enter for things I want. It’s a decent rule and it’s not the real one, because I did want that trip. I thought I wanted it a lot.
The real variable was how much each prize asked of me compared to what I had to give that season.
Atlanta asked me to get on a plane and then follow a schedule someone else had already built. Hard, and possible. I was an anxious traveler the entire time I was there. I want to be clear about that, because I’m not telling you to only enter for easy things. I did the hard thing while anxious, and it counted.
The Sports Dream Package asked me to plan a trip from scratch, pick the event, pick the city, pick the dates, and make a dozen decisions in a year when I couldn’t reliably make one. Fewer decisions meant fewer places to get stuck. That sentence explains more of my life than I’m comfortable with.
Capacity isn’t comfort. It’s not about avoiding hard things. It’s about knowing what this season of your life can carry, which changes, and which has nothing to do with how badly you want the thing.
What I do about it now, twenty years later
I don’t enter for trips. Or concerts. Or anything requiring an outing.
That filter runs before a sweepstakes ever reaches my tracker. I use Sweepsheet, a subscription service I’ve paid for for years to find and vet sweeps (not my product, not sponsored, no affiliate deal, I’m just a customer), and I screen those categories out there. They never become records. They never get entered.
It isn’t a sad rule and I’m not writing it wistfully. It’s protection, and it works. I still enter a couple hundred sweeps a month and I still get a real kick out of a $10 gift card showing up. I wrote about exactly what that returns in my real sweepstakes win rate, and the full log of what I’ve won since 2005 is on my winnings page.
One prize I couldn’t claim in 2005 rewrote what I let myself want from this hobby for two decades. I’m fine with the trade.
How do you know what your capacity is?
Ask before you enter, not after you win. The question isn’t do I want this. It’s could I claim this.
Today’s action
Before your next entry, ask one question: if I won this tomorrow, could I actually claim it in the season I’m in right now?
Not the season you’re heading toward. Not the version of you who has more energy. Today’s season. If the answer is no, skip it, and don’t treat that as wasting your luck. It’s aim.
Planting seeds is the whole idea here, and I’ll keep saying it. But a seed you can’t tend isn’t a seed, it’s a chore with a deadline. Growing your own luck includes knowing which ground you can actually water this year.
Frequently asked questions
Do you have to pay taxes on a prize you never claimed?
Often yes. I was 1099’d on the combined value of two trips, including one I never took. Prizes count as income, and the paperwork tends to follow the award rather than your use of it. If a big win arrives and you know you can’t use it, talk to whoever does your taxes early rather than after the form shows up.
Can you give away a sweepstakes prize you can’t use?
Usually not. Most large prizes are non-transferrable, which is written into the official rules, and mine was. You can decline a prize before accepting it, which is a different thing and generally the cleaner move if you already know it’s unusable.
What happens if you don’t claim a sweepstakes prize?
The official rules decide. Some sweeps draw an alternate winner if you don’t respond in time, and some let the prize simply expire and reach nobody. That second outcome is what happened to mine, and it’s the reason I stopped treating an unused prize as harmless.
Should I enter sweepstakes for trips?
Only if you could claim one in the season you’re in. Trips carry the most friction of any prize category: dates, travel, time off, and taxes on a large value. I’ve cut them completely and I don’t miss them. If your life has room for a trip right now, enter away.
How do I figure out my own capacity?
Look at what you managed in the last month, not what you managed in your best month ever. Capacity is a moving number and it responds to what’s happening in your life. Mine in 2005 could handle a scheduled trip and could not handle an open-ended one, and knowing that difference would have saved me a lot.
The short version
Prizes you can’t claim aren’t free to walk away from. You can still owe tax on them, and if they’re non-transferrable, nobody else gets them either. Enter for the capacity you have this season instead of the capacity you wish you had, and you’ll plant fewer seeds you can’t tend.
I still enter almost every day. I just aim differently now. Pick one thing you could genuinely say yes to tomorrow, and enter that one.
A tool I built
Dopamine Dealer
Track your habits and get a hit of dopamine every time you check one off. No willpower required.
Start your streak →I run an affiliate program on the tools I build. Approved affiliates earn 20% on what their referrals pay, for up to a year. US only for now. See the program →
